Contributor - Accidents and Regulations

Contributor - Accidents and Regulations

Gordon Gilbert

A review of U.S.-registered business turbine airplane accidents from 2010 through 2016 by AIN reveals that during the seven-year period there were 406 total accidents—141 involving jets and 265 involving turboprops. By far the most numerous type of accident during the study period was the runway excursion, primarily on landing, though typically the damage in these mishaps was minor with no injuries. Still, investigators blamed many of these mishaps&nbsp;on the flight crew’s lack of proper approach procedures or failure to recognize and be prepared for likely circumstances that could result from, for example, a wet, icy or snowy runway.


The least number of fatalities occurred in 2010 for both jets and turboprops. In that year, there was one fatal business jet accident (Part 91) in which two people lost their lives. In 2010, twelve people were killed in four accidents involving turboprops, three under Part 91 and one under Part 135.


There have never been any fatal accidents involving Part 91K turbine airplanes. However, fractional jet operators suffered five nonfatal mishaps and fractional turboprops were in three nonfatal accidents during the study time frame. &nbsp;


In the seven-year period studied, the worst year for jet fatal accidents and fatalities was 2012, when 31 people died in six accidents. A strikingly similar tally followed&nbsp;in 2014, when 30 people died, also in six accidents. For turboprops, 2013 saw 45 deaths&nbsp;in 15 accidents.&nbsp;There was one fatal accident each for a public/government operation and a manufacturer’s test flight over the study period. The single fatal accident by a manufacturer in the study period happened on April 2, 2011,&nbsp;when<a href="http://www.ainonline.com/aviation-news/2011-04-02/gulfstream-g650-test-airplane-crashes-new-mexico"> a Gulfstream G650 crashed on takeoff for a planned test flight</a>. The four occupants were killed.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;


<h2>Private versus Air Taxi </h2>


A closer examination of the data in the accompanying charts and tables tells the rest of the story: more accidents and fatalities befell turboprops than jets. In both the jet and turboprop segments, Part 91 operations had more accidents and deaths than Part 135 missions. Air-taxi operators incurred fatal accidents in two of the seven years for jets. However, for turboprops, air-taxi flights were involved in fatal accidents for all but one year. Part 91 jets and turboprops were involved in fatal accidents every year from 2010 through 2016, with the exception of 2011, when there were no Part 91 fatal jet accidents. The only jet accident in 2011 was the aforementioned G650. &nbsp;


The single Part 91 fatal accident in 2010 happened on January 5 when a Learjet 35 on a positioning flight in day VMC crashed while maneuvering in the traffic pattern for landing. The two pilots were killed. The NTSB concluded that control of the airplane was lost for undetermined reasons. Nevertheless, the Safety Board said the CVR showed multiple instances that when the airplane was below 10,000 feet msl the pilots were in discussions “not consistent with a sterile cockpit environment.”&nbsp;In addition, the Safety Board found that the pilots appear to have conducted checklists in a “generally informal manner.”


There were other fatal accidents in which the NTSB placed blame on the crew. The one during the study period that generated the most repercussions for the business aviation community was the May 31, 2014, crash of a Gulfstream IV that took the lives of all seven occupants. The aircraft, on a planned Part 91 flight, crashed while attempting to take&nbsp;off from Hanscom Field in Bedford, Mass.&nbsp;Among many causal factors cited by the Safety Board was the discovery that the <a href="http://www.ainonline.com/aviation-news/business-aviation/2015-04-08/ntsb-docket-reveals-cockpit-warning-giv-crash">pilots had a history of not using checklists</a> or checking for full and free movement of the flight controls&nbsp;before takeoff. Serious accidents that involve not conforming to recommended procedures, such as in the aforementioned Learjet 35 and GIV examples, are not a rarity for either Part 91 or 135 flights, according to Safety Board reports.


<h2>Part 135 Jet Fatals</h2>


Ten people were killed in two Part 135 jet accidents during the study period. On Dec. 9, 2012, all seven people on an N-numbered Learjet 25 lost their lives when the twinjet, cruising at FL280 in Mexican airspace, suddenly entered a high-speed descent and crashed in mountainous terrain at 9,000 feet msl. The aircraft did not have a CVR, and although there was an FDR, investigators were unable to recover any information. The Mexican DGAC concluded that the there was a “loss of aircraft control for undetermined reasons.”


On Nov. 10, 2015, a Hawker 125 on an air-taxi flight stalled and crashed on approach&nbsp;to Akron, Ohio. The nine people aboard were killed. The NTSB faulted the pilots for “mismanagement of the approach and multiple deviations from company SOPs, which led to an unstabilized approach, a descent below MDA without visual contact with the runway environment, and an aerodynamic stall.”


AIN selected 2010 as the starting point for this study because that was the first full year that&nbsp;AIN&nbsp;began in-house researching of accident and incident data. Before then,&nbsp;AIN&nbsp;reported on statistics provided by a reliable&nbsp;but external source. By compiling data in house,&nbsp;AIN&nbsp;can more thoroughly analyze accident reports and publish even more accurate numbers. &nbsp;&nbsp;

News and information on safety procedures and concerns.

Runway Excursions Most Common Type of Bizav Accident

There were 406 total accidents (jets and turboprops) between 2010 and 2016.

2024 Corporate Aviation Leadership Summit

Amy Wilder

News and issues relating to business, corporate and private aviation, primarily regarding turbine-engine-powered airplanes and helicopters. Subjects include aircraft, engines, maintenance, operations, personnel, acquisitions, accidents, safety, security, and training.

Altitude and course deviation, traffic proximity remain top categories

ACSF Data Shows Stable Bizav Risk Amid 2026 Pressures

Kerry Lynch

News and issues relating to international air transport and cargo carriers, national airlines and regional airlines, including aircraft, engines, personnel, acquisitions, accidents, safety, security and training.

Essential news and analysis on the defense aerospace business. Your trusted source for new and ongoing programs and requirements in military aircraft (manned and unmanned), engines, avionics, weapons and associated systems, including ground-based air defense.

Aircraft remained within separation guidance but neared each other after the presidential helicopter was unable to alert ATC

Faulty Comms Preceded Marine One/Envoy Close Call

Graham leaving agency within months of confirmation to another term

NTSB Vice Chair Michael Graham To Retire October 2

Stuart “Kipp” Lau

News about bills, laws, regulations and other governmental decisions affecting aviation and aerospace. Topics include FAA re-authorizations, taxes on fuel and aviation activities, environmental legislation, ICAO decisions, governmental mediation of labor conflicts and World Trade Organization disputes and decisions.

UK CAA concerned over rise in unstable approaches continuing to land

AINsight: Go-arounds Are a Normal and Expected Outcome

News about significant aircraft accidents and information from accident reports.

News and issues regarding all manner of civil and military rotorcraft and their powerplants, including helicopters, tilt rotors and unmanned air vehicles.

Helicopters more than twice as vulnerable to loss of visual reference accidents than airplanes

TSB: Rotorcraft More Prone To Loss-of-visual-reference Accidents

Charlotte Bailey

News about environmental issues relating to aircraft operations, including noise issues, emissisions, and regulations. See Fuel for biofuel.

News and issues relating to the aerospace industry that are related to the science, engineering and business of flight in space involving civil, industrial and military applications, and similar topics related to flight in the atmosphere of the Earth that are not covered more directly by other AINonline subject channels. In other words, both astronautical and aeronautical subjects, except for those aeronautical topics that are specifically covered elsewhere on this website.

More In Safety

ACSF Data Shows Stable Bizav Risk Amid 2026 Pressures

Altitude and course deviation, traffic proximity remain top categories

Faulty Comms Preceded Marine One/Envoy Close Call

Aircraft remained within separation guidance but neared each other after the presidential helicopter was unable to alert ATC

NTSB Vice Chair Michael Graham To Retire October 2

Graham leaving agency within months of confirmation to another term

AINsight: Go-arounds Are a Normal and Expected Outcome

UK CAA concerned over rise in unstable approaches continuing to land

TSB: Rotorcraft More Prone To Loss-of-visual-reference Accidents

Helicopters more than twice as vulnerable to loss of visual reference accidents than airplanes

EASA: Atmospheric Icing Insufficiently Understood

European air safety agency calls for more comprehensive studies into phenomenon

Embry-Riddle Introduces ‘Safer Skies’ Video Podcasts

First episode features three-time space shuttle veteranJanet Kavandi

Li-ion Thermal Runaways on the Rise in Aircraft Cabins

Numbers are rising and the risk of a serious incident is increasing

AIN Products

SUBSCRIPTIONS

RESOURCES

ABOUT AIN