Sean Broderick's aviation career started in 1991, working for Airbus in Toulouse. His industry experience includes four years with an aviation consultancy, where he worked on the successful launch of a U.S. Part 121 carrier; 12 years with an airport association as a magazine editor and communications executive; and more than 15 years of full- and part-time work as a journalist, writing about air transport and business aviation. &nbsp;
&nbsp;

Writer

Sean Broderick

Aircraft operators and air traffic management stakeholders can make U.S. airspace safer by improving weather reporting protocol and being more diligent about ensuring the right people get clear, consistent data in a timely manner, an NTSB study on pilot weather reports (Pireps) found.


The report, “Improving Pilot Weather Report Submission and Dissemination to Benefit Safety in the National Airspace System,” was prompted by findings in 16 NTSB investigations from 2012&nbsp;to 2015 that spotlighted areas of concern. In two instances, the Board identified failure to deliver Pireps to flight crews as a contributing factor. In the other probes, the NTSB identified Pirep-related shortcomings but determined they did not play a prominent role in the incidents and accidents.


“The prevalence of these issues across numerous investigations, as well as the similarities between these issues and the concerns voiced by Pirep user groups, suggests that such problems are widespread,” the NTSB wrote in the report, which was adopted on March 29. “The NTSB believes that correcting these systemic Pirep-related issues can help reduce the occurrence of hazardous weather encounters in the NAS.”


<h2>Smoother Dissemination Process</h2>


The report focuses on three broad themes: pilots need to make more submissions to bolster data quantity; submissions must be more accurate; and Pireps must be turned around and distributed quickly and consistently to be more useful. &nbsp;


Pireps are filed with air traffic controllers, flight service stations or company dispatchers. The reports are then distributed locally and, in many cases, nationally for use by other pilots, weather forecasters and dispatchers, among others. The NTSB’s findings suggest that the Pirep process breaks down most often at the dissemination stage. The NTSB found issues with distributing Pireps in 12 of the 16 investigations—including 10 fatal accidents—that prompted its study.&nbsp;


In one case, in March 2012, a Learjet 35A flew through severe icing on approach to Anchorage, Alaska. The windshield iced over and the pilots lost all forward visibility. The aircraft veered off the runway after touchdown and ended up in a snow bank.&nbsp;The NTSB found that 15 minutes before the Learjet flew through the icing conditions, the controller handling the flight learned from a tower controller at&nbsp;Elmendorf Air Force Base, 7 miles away, that an F-16 pilot broke off an approach because of severe icing that coated his canopy.


“The Elmendorf tower controller used good judgment in sharing the severe icing Pirep with the Anchorage facility,” the NTSB said. “However, the Anchorage approach controller did not relay the urgent Pirep to the Learjet flight crew (or the pilot of another aircraft operating near Anchorage), which the NTSB found to be a contributing factor to the incident.”


In August 2015, an Airbus A320 flight crew declared an emergency after suffering a shattered windshield and airframe damage when flying through a hail storm over Nebraska. The Safety Board found that the flight crew had asked en&nbsp;route controllers “repeatedly” for Pireps from the area before heading into the weather, and received none. The Board learned that one Denver en&nbsp;route center controller handling the flight had relevant Pireps but failed to relay them.


In several instances the Board found controllers failed to request Pireps despite reported or forecasted conditions—such as ceilings below 5,000 feet, turbulence, wind shear or icing—that required them to do so.&nbsp;The requirements help, as one survey showed that half of a set of GA pilots do not voluntarily submit Pireps, but “typically respond” when prompted by a controller or flight services specialist.


Data accuracy is another common problem, the NTSB found. In addition to incorrect information, that category encompasses Pireps that are not coded correctly or cannot be read by automated systems within the Pirep ecosystem, and therefore may not get distributed properly or at all.&nbsp;


“For example, a CWSU meteorologist pointed out that the AWC website, which displays graphical depictions of Pireps information, cannot process Pireps that contain typographical or formatting errors,” the NTSB explained. “Thus, Pireps containing such errors may not be disseminated to the NAS.”


A recent FAA policy change may be adding to the poor data-quality issue. Beginning in March last year, controllers in terminal facilities were required to enter Pireps into the Aviation Information System Replacement (AIS-R) repository instead of passing them on to Lockheed Martin Flight Services, the FAA’s flight service contract provider, for entry. The move, which an FAA memorandum on the changes says was made to cut costs, coincided with an uptick in errors. “For example, urgent reports have been coded as routine, a flight level that translated to '400,000 feet' was reported, and the text elements of some Pireps were transcribed using full words, rather than the abbreviated codes upon which other systems rely for display processing,” the NTSB found.


<h2>Cooperative Effort</h2>


The dissemination and data-accuracy issues led the NTSB to make five recommendations to the FAA that target the air traffic controller’s role in the Pirep processes. The Board asked the agency to work with the National Air Traffic Controllers Association to review best practices for both soliciting and disseminating Pireps; incorporate real-world scenarios into controller training that emphasizes the value of fair- and adverse-weather Pireps; review and revise controller training to provide two sets of automated tools to help controllers collect accurate Pirep information and import existing data from their systems; and revise internal FAA orders to emphasize Pirep particulars, specifically “coding, handling, solicitation and dissemination.”


Meanwhile, the NTSB identified a clear disconnect between pilots’ views on the importance of Pireps and their willingness to submit them.&nbsp;An AOPA survey found that 83&nbsp;percent &nbsp;of pilots viewed Pireps as “extremely or very important” to aviation safety, yet voluntary submissions trend far below this. The Board pointed to several reasons, such as a lack of awareness of filing Pireps that support as-forecasted conditions, and a lack of confidence in the pilot’s ability to judge the weather or follow proper reporting procedures.


Another challenge identified by pilots: the workload involved in submitting a Pirep from the flight deck. Pilots responding to the AOPA survey cited the hassle of having to locate the correct flight-service station frequency and then both deliver the information and validate read-backs from the FSS representative. Part of the challenge is that, unlike controllers, FSS personnel have no information about the aircraft they are talking to, so pilots must communicate basic information such as aircraft type and altitude in addition to the core weather-observation data.


The process “is having an unintended deterrent effect on reporting because some pilots find the process too time-consuming and therefore choose not to submit,” the NTSB said. The Board recommended that the FAA review the process and simplify procedures with an eye to saving time.


As a result, the Safety Board issued recommendations to the&nbsp;FAA, AOPA Air Safety Institute, the Aviation Accreditation Board International, the National Association of Flight Instructors and the Society of Aviation and Flight Educators to improve Pirep-focused training for student pilots, emphasizing their importance as well as when and how to file them.&nbsp;


The NTSB zeroed in on FAA limitations that excludePireps older than one hour from the submission system. While older reports often have little value in flight planning, they are valuable to meteorologists for forecasting. The Board recommended that the FAA expand the acceptance window by at least several hours.


Another shortcoming identified by the NTSB and confirmed by the FAA: few Pireps are filed during overnight hours. The Board recommended that the Cargo Airline Association, which reaches operators that fly the majority of the overnight flights, encourage more reporting from pilots and dispatchers.


The Board made 19 recommendations in the study. At press time, the Board had not acknowledged receipt of any responses.

News and information on safety procedures and concerns.

Pirep Process Has Room For Improvement, NTSB Study Finds

Both controllers and pilots could do more to ensure that operators have the most relevant, up-to-date information.

2024 Corporate Aviation Leadership Summit

Amy Wilder

News and issues relating to business, corporate and private aviation, primarily regarding turbine-engine-powered airplanes and helicopters. Subjects include aircraft, engines, maintenance, operations, personnel, acquisitions, accidents, safety, security, and training.

Altitude and course deviation, traffic proximity remain top categories

ACSF Data Shows Stable Bizav Risk Amid 2026 Pressures

Kerry Lynch

News and issues relating to international air transport and cargo carriers, national airlines and regional airlines, including aircraft, engines, personnel, acquisitions, accidents, safety, security and training.

Essential news and analysis on the defense aerospace business. Your trusted source for new and ongoing programs and requirements in military aircraft (manned and unmanned), engines, avionics, weapons and associated systems, including ground-based air defense.

Aircraft remained within separation guidance but neared each other after the presidential helicopter was unable to alert ATC

Faulty Comms Preceded Marine One/Envoy Close Call

Graham leaving agency within months of confirmation to another term

NTSB Vice Chair Michael Graham To Retire October 2

Stuart “Kipp” Lau

News about bills, laws, regulations and other governmental decisions affecting aviation and aerospace. Topics include FAA re-authorizations, taxes on fuel and aviation activities, environmental legislation, ICAO decisions, governmental mediation of labor conflicts and World Trade Organization disputes and decisions.

UK CAA concerned over rise in unstable approaches continuing to land

AINsight: Go-arounds Are a Normal and Expected Outcome

News about significant aircraft accidents and information from accident reports.

News and issues regarding all manner of civil and military rotorcraft and their powerplants, including helicopters, tilt rotors and unmanned air vehicles.

Helicopters more than twice as vulnerable to loss of visual reference accidents than airplanes

TSB: Rotorcraft More Prone To Loss-of-visual-reference Accidents

Charlotte Bailey

News about environmental issues relating to aircraft operations, including noise issues, emissisions, and regulations. See Fuel for biofuel.

News and issues relating to the aerospace industry that are related to the science, engineering and business of flight in space involving civil, industrial and military applications, and similar topics related to flight in the atmosphere of the Earth that are not covered more directly by other AINonline subject channels. In other words, both astronautical and aeronautical subjects, except for those aeronautical topics that are specifically covered elsewhere on this website.

More In Safety

ACSF Data Shows Stable Bizav Risk Amid 2026 Pressures

Altitude and course deviation, traffic proximity remain top categories

Faulty Comms Preceded Marine One/Envoy Close Call

Aircraft remained within separation guidance but neared each other after the presidential helicopter was unable to alert ATC

NTSB Vice Chair Michael Graham To Retire October 2

Graham leaving agency within months of confirmation to another term

AINsight: Go-arounds Are a Normal and Expected Outcome

UK CAA concerned over rise in unstable approaches continuing to land

TSB: Rotorcraft More Prone To Loss-of-visual-reference Accidents

Helicopters more than twice as vulnerable to loss of visual reference accidents than airplanes

EASA: Atmospheric Icing Insufficiently Understood

European air safety agency calls for more comprehensive studies into phenomenon

Embry-Riddle Introduces ‘Safer Skies’ Video Podcasts

First episode features three-time space shuttle veteranJanet Kavandi

Li-ion Thermal Runaways on the Rise in Aircraft Cabins

Numbers are rising and the risk of a serious incident is increasing

AIN Products

SUBSCRIPTIONS

RESOURCES

ABOUT AIN