Mark Huber is an aviation industry veteran who has worked in the flight training, aircraft sales, aircraft component, and airport development businesses. He has flight time in more than 50 different and diverse aircraft, including helicopters, aerobatic aircraft, vintage warbirds, jet fighters, business jets and turboprops, and transport-category aircraft. He has jumped out of several of these—on purpose—with a parachute. His defense and aviation journalism has been published in a variety of national and international periodicals.

Contributor

Mark Huber

The U.S. Department of Transportation’s Office of Inspector General (IG) criticized the FAA’s supervision of “doors-off” helitour operators in a recently released audit&nbsp;<a href="https://www.oig.dot.gov/sites/default/files/FAA%20Helicopter%20Air%20Tour%20Final%20Report%2012.8.20--508%20Compliant-fixed.pdf">report</a>. That audit was requested by New York’s two U.S. senators in 2019 following the March 2018 fatal crash of a FlyNYON doors-off tour.

 


In that accident, all five passengers remained strapped in and drowned after the Airbus AS350B2, operated for FlyNYON by Liberty Helicopters, successfully autorotated into the East River, but then rolled inverted after its emergency pop-out floats failed to fully deploy. Physical and electronic accident evidence showed that the passengers were unable to extricate themselves from the commercial, off-the-shelf supplemental restraints they were wearing.

 


The NTSB&nbsp;subsequently discovered that the FAA had not evaluated these passenger harnesses and the FAA subsequently placed new restrictions for the restraint systems on doors-off flights that included requirements that operators obtain an FAA letter of authorization (LOA) for the restraint systems used and that those restraints “can be quickly released by a passenger with minimal difficulty and without impeding egress from the aircraft in an emergency.”

 


The IG concluded the FAA “did not maintain effective and consistent oversight of open-door helicopter operations to maintain the safety of air tour passengers; FAA lacks an effective process to review, authorize, and ensure the safe use of supplemental restraints for open-door helicopter operations; and FAA inspectors lack sufficient guidance to oversee operator use of supplemental passenger restraints.” While the IG noted that the FAA has made some progress on the issue via the LOA requirement, it concluded, “that that authorization process is still-evolving and important risk information has been overlooked. Also, FAA does not currently provide the guidance inspectors need to ensure operators are using and maintaining the supplemental restraints the agency has authorized.”&nbsp;

 


The IG recommended that the FAA issue a final rule on supplemental passenger restraints; require review of those restraints via standardized checklist to obtain an LOA; define aviation-specific certification load standards for the restraints; revise LOA authorization procedures so applications have local inspection oversight; and provide inspector guidance with regard to&nbsp;the use of supplemental restraints by both Part 135 and 91 operators.&nbsp;

 


Doors-off, or “shoe selfie,” tours are gaining in popularity as helitour operators look to attract a younger clientele and increase revenue in increasingly more restrictive, hostile political and economic environments, particularly in the New York City area. U.S. Sen. Charles Schumer (D) has been a persistent critic of civil helicopters in his state, but particularly helitours, repeatedly calling them “dangerous.”

 


The shoe-selfie tours also have long been criticized by leading industry and safety groups, including the Helicopter Association International (HAI). The IG noted in its audit report that “air tours accounted for 10 percent of all helicopter operations in the United States for the last 10 years but make up the fifth-largest category for flight hours—behind aerial observation/law enforcement, training, air ambulance, and off-shore flights. The Department of the Interior reported that a total of 47,145 air tours were conducted over the National Park system in 2018—one of the only places where air tour reporting is required.”&nbsp;

 


Via way of formal audit response from FAA director of the office of audit and evaluation H. Clayton Foushee, the agency said that it agreed with most of the IG’s recommendations, but noted, “When developing its submission and evaluation processes for non-required SPRS (supplemental passenger restraint systems), the FAA recognized that acceptable and established minimum standards for supplemental restraints already exist and are in use in other FAA evaluation scenarios and in many occupations. The FAA considers these existing standards when reviewing submission packages. Additionally, FAA recognizes that SPRS are carry-on devices; as a result, the FAA does not certify them. In this regard, SPRS are not subject to the high aviation load factors the FAA applies when evaluating and approving seats and seatbelts. This distinction is appropriate, as SPRS are designed to keep an individual inside the helicopter, while approved seats and seatbelts are designed for emergency landing conditions.”&nbsp;

News and issues regarding all manner of civil and military rotorcraft and their powerplants, including helicopters, tilt rotors and unmanned air vehicles.

DOT Watchdog Gives FAA Fresh 'Doors Off' Upbraiding

DOT IG critical of FAA current supervision of "doors off" helitour flights. 

2024 Corporate Aviation Leadership Summit

Neelam Mathews

News and information on safety procedures and concerns.

Essential news and analysis on the defense aerospace business. Your trusted source for new and ongoing programs and requirements in military aircraft (manned and unmanned), engines, avionics, weapons and associated systems, including ground-based air defense.

News and issues concerning general aviation, specifically airplanes and helicopters powered by piston and alternative engines (i.e., non-turbine powered aircraft). Subjects include aircraft, engines, personnel, acquisitions, accidents, safety, security and training.

Nepal’s army and private operators have deployed rotorcraft across the flood zone

Helicopters Play Crucial Role in Himalayan Flood Rescues

Charlotte Bailey

News about bills, laws, regulations and other governmental decisions affecting aviation and aerospace. Topics include FAA re-authorizations, taxes on fuel and aviation activities, environmental legislation, ICAO decisions, governmental mediation of labor conflicts and World Trade Organization disputes and decisions.

Pentagon permission facilitates sale of Bell 412EXP and 407M

U.S. Approves $800M Bell 407/412 Sale to Iraq Military

News and issues relating to the aerospace industry that are related to the science, engineering and business of flight in space involving civil, industrial and military applications, and similar topics related to flight in the atmosphere of the Earth that are not covered more directly by other AINonline subject channels. In other words, both astronautical and aeronautical subjects, except for those aeronautical topics that are specifically covered elsewhere on this website.

Fire and disaster management agency to use aircraft in aerial reconnaissance role

Japan Orders Its First H160 for Emergency Response

Flights with two scaled technology demonstrators will inform potential future iterations 

Singaporean eVTOL Conducts Test Campaign In Germany 

Matt Thurber

New developments and products in avionics, specifically about aircraft electronics in the cockpit.

News and issues relating to business, corporate and private aviation, primarily regarding turbine-engine-powered airplanes and helicopters. Subjects include aircraft, engines, maintenance, operations, personnel, acquisitions, accidents, safety, security, and training.

More In Rotorcraft

Helicopters Play Crucial Role in Himalayan Flood Rescues

Nepal’s army and private operators have deployed rotorcraft across the flood zone

U.S. Approves $800M Bell 407/412 Sale to Iraq Military

Pentagon permission facilitates sale of Bell 412EXP and 407M

Japan Orders Its First H160 for Emergency Response

Fire and disaster management agency to use aircraft in aerial reconnaissance role

Singaporean eVTOL Conducts Test Campaign In Germany

Flights with two scaled technology demonstrators will inform potential future iterations

FAA Approves TSO for ASU Panoramic Night-vision Goggles

Lightweight white-phosphor NVG have a 94-degree field of view

FAA Floats Special Conditions for Skyryse Fly-by-wire R66

Proposed rule addresses pilot awareness of control limits

Vertical Lift Groups Extend Trade Show Partnership

European Helicopter Association and Vertical Aviation International extended their alliance

Sikorsky Is Upgrading the Black Hawk Helicopter for Evolving Military Needs

Armed forces will be able to outfit Black Hawks with new armament and equipment.

AIN Products

SUBSCRIPTIONS

RESOURCES

ABOUT AIN