AINsight: Criminalization of Aviation Accidents Is a Genuine Concern | Aviation International News

AINsight: Criminalization in Aviation a Genuine Concern

Punishing flight crewmembers for mistakes impedes safety advancements

Joe Sharkey and damaged Legacy — Joe Sharkey was one of the passengers in this Embraer Legacy 600 that was involved in a midair collision in Brazil. (Photo courtesy of the author)

By Stuart “Kipp” Lau • Contributor - Safety

March 28, 2025

Criminalization of aviation incidents and accidents—and its unintended consequences—holds the potential to negatively affect aviation safety and jeopardize a positive reporting culture. Outside of the U.S., there has been a steady increase in legal actions against flight crewmembers and other aviation workers.

Often, dual investigations are initiated following an incident or accident. The technical investigation focuses on improving flight safety. Whereas a judicial investigation aims to determine fault and blameworthiness for actions that may lead to criminal or civil liability and subsequent prosecution.

The rest of this article continues for AIN Members with the full report, analysis and background. The rest of this article continues for AIN Members with the full report, analysis and background. The rest of this article continues for AIN Members with the full report, analysis and background. The rest of this article continues for AIN Members with the full report, analysis and background. The rest of this article continues for AIN Members with the full report, analysis and background.

The rest of this article continues for AIN Members with the full report, analysis and background. The rest of this article continues for AIN Members with the full report, analysis and background. The rest of this article continues for AIN Members with the full report, analysis and background.

The rest of this article continues for AIN Members with the full report, analysis and background. The rest of this article continues for AIN Members with the full report, analysis and background. The rest of this article continues for AIN Members with the full report, analysis and background. The rest of this article continues for AIN Members with the full report, analysis and background. The rest of this article continues for AIN Members with the full report, analysis and background. The rest of this article continues for AIN Members with the full report, analysis and background.

The rest of this article continues for AIN Members with the full report, analysis and background. The rest of this article continues for AIN Members with the full report, analysis and background. The rest of this article continues for AIN Members with the full report, analysis and background. The rest of this article continues for AIN Members with the full report, analysis and background.

Stuart “Kipp” Lau

Contributor - Safety

About the author

Pilot, safety expert, consultant, and aviation journalist Stuart “Kipp” Lau writes about flight safety and airmanship for AIN.

See more by this author

AINsight: Does Pilot Flight Time Equate to Competency?

Not all logged flight hours are created equal

Pilots in cockpit

FAA Rescinding Cessna Citation Single-pilot Exemptions

Action comes after a review found widespread noncompliance and safety issues

Citation jet bird strike through flock of birds

Thales Opens Center To Elevate Safety Culture

Facility initially serves Bordeaux campus but will expand to other locations

Thales Flight Safety Center

FAA Floats Allowing Jet Pilots To Forego Wearing O2 Masks

Part 91 pilots would not have to wear masks "just in case," while 135 rules would allow higher altitudes

Cessna Citation 560 business jet accident

APS Unveils Pilatus Aircraft Family Upset Recovery Course

Progam is tailored for the PC-12 and PC-24 community

Pilatus PC-12 in flight

Bombardier’s 30th Safety Standdown Opens Registration

Free three-day seminar open to all aviation professionals

Registration is open for Bombardier’s 30th annual Safety Standdown seminar, a free, three-day event in Wichita, Kansas, this November.

NATA Ground Handling Safety Symposium Reaches a Decade

The conference spanned two days for the first time in its history

NATA president and CEO Curt Castagna addresses the audience

Ex-astronaut Touts Operational Excellence at CJP Confab

Preparation and judgement key for aviators

Retired NASA astronaut Butch Willmore