The European Business Aviation Association (EBAA) has prepared new guidance on the key distinctions between private aircraft operations and what it referred to as “disguised commercial air transport.” The position paper was developed after discussions with EASA to provide information that could support more effective enforcement action against illegal charter flights.
During a discussion at the EBAA Week Airops conference on Wednesday, speakers presented instances demonstrating that so-called “gray” operations are exploiting gaps in understanding as to what it takes for a for-hire flight to be legal. The EBAA position paper addresses this by clarifying key points such as operational control of the aircraft and the ensuing responsibilities of aircraft operators, brokers, and their clients.
Sascha Schott, section manager at EASA’s Air Operations Standards Directorate, said he was surprised to discover that illegal charter continues to be such a problem when he took on the role. He said his division is working on nonbinding guidance to help national aviation authorities in EASA member states better understand the basis for enforcement.
Maxime Wauters, a senior first officer with a Belgian charter operator and senior manager for regulatory affairs with EBAA, has been involved in drafting the industry group’s position paper. “We have both a safety problem and a level playing field problem, and it seems that those [operators] who play by the rules get the hardest time from [local regulators],” he told conference attendees.
Wauters recounted how when operating a charter flight to a Swiss airport in an Embraer Praetor, his crew were subjected to an extensive ramp check by local officials. While waiting for this to be completed, he noticed a Pilatus PC-12 parked nearby that, in his view, was clearly conducting an illegal charter and was boarding more passengers than he considered safe as ice and snow accumulated on the aircraft’s wings. He brought this to the attention of the officials, who told him they didn’t have time to check on that situation.
Terry Yeomans, IBAC’s IS-BAH program director, described how in a previous role with a flight-planning group he had been asked to prepare a permit for a charter operation that he knew would be illegal. After declining the request, he reported it to UK officials, providing full information about the planned departure time and location. He was told the agency had no one available to check on the flight and then contacted the police, who were also unwilling to respond.
Nicolas Fischel, a business aviation attorney and secretary of EBAA France, explained that ambiguities continue in how operational control of commercial flights is interpreted legally. He highlighted an incident in France in which a pilot and an operator successfully appealed against a conviction for illegal charter.
The aircraft in question had been “rented” via a “joint venture” through which “members” cover costs collectively. The original trial found against the pilot and operator because the members were not aware that the company involved did not have an air operator certificate. But the appeals judge overturned this decision, leaving the prosecutor to acknowledge that “gray areas” had undermined the case.
“As a charter client, when you sign a contract, you are responsible and need to understand all the consequences,” Fischel stated.