Gregory Polek has spent his entire career in aviation journalism with AIN, starting as a proofreader and assistant to then-managing editor Mary Mahoney in 1995 after serving an internship with&nbsp;New Jersey Monthly&nbsp;magazine and completing his B.A. degree in English/Writing at New Jersey’s William Paterson College. By 1997 Polek accepted a position as an associate editor, covering the regional airline beat for&nbsp;Aviation International News&nbsp;in place of retiring industry veteran Don Anderson. The assignment took Polek across North America and Europe to profile regional airlines varying in size and mission from the likes of floatplane operators Kenmore Air and Chalk’s Ocean Airways to regional jet operators such as SkyWest and American Eagle. Today, in his dual role as Air Transport Editor and International Airshow Editor, Polek writes, edits, and manages AIN’s commercial aviation content while overseeing each of the company’s daily international air show publications in Paris, Farnborough, Singapore, and Dubai. Most recently Polek has assumed oversight of daily coverage of the Helicopter Association International’s annual Heli-Expo convention.

Senior Editor

Gregory Polek

The National Transportation Safety Board on Tuesday published a second round of comments detailing concerns with several findings in the Ethiopian Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau's (EAIB)&nbsp;final report on the March 10, 2019, crash of an Ethiopian Airlines Boeing 737 Max 8. The comments come less than a month after the NTSB protested what it called the investigation’s insufficient attention to the human performance aspects of the accident.
Although the NTSB said it agrees with the finding in the EAIB report related to the role the Maneuvering Characteristics Augmentation System (MCAS) and related systems played in the accident, the report also contains findings not supported by evidence, according to the Safety Board. For example, the NTSB specifically cites the EAIB’s conclusion that aircraft electrical problems caused erroneous angle-of-attack (AOA) output.&nbsp;
In its final report, the EAIB wrote electrical anomalies that existed since the time of the accident airplane’s production caused the AOA sensor heater to fail. As a result, the Ethiopian authority added, the AOA sensor provided erroneous values that caused the MCAS to repeatedly pitch the nose of the airplane downward until it struck the ground.
The NTSB, however, found that impact with a foreign object, most likely a bird, resulted in the separation of the AOA sensor vane, causing erroneous readings. The NTSB added that it provided the EAIB with evidence that supports the finding of a foreign object strike during the accident investigation, but the EAIB failed to include it in the final report.
According to the EAIB, an open circuit, wire fatigue, multiple arcing events, unexplained electrical/electronic anomalies, and the loss of heater power led to the failure of the originally installed and tested Boeing AOA sensor. The U.S. team believes that an electrical failure affecting the left AOA sensor did not occur before the left AOA vane’s impact with a foreign object, said the NTSB.
“The conditions present at the time of the accident were above freezing temperatures with no moisture present (that is, ice could not form regardless of the heater’s operational status),” the NTSB commented. “Thus, a loss of electrical current through the vane heater at any time during the accident flight would not explain the event because the loss of electrical current would have had no effect on the AOA sensor output. Another factor that occurred simultaneously with the loss of the AOA sensor vane heater’s electrical current would have been required to cause the observed change in the AOA output signal.”
Additionally, the NTSB said the AOA sensor vane heater and the two internal AOA resolvers operate on different electrical circuits, so a loss of electrical current in the AOA sensor vane heater does not indicate an electrical failure of the two internal AOA resolvers. The accident FDR data showed no indication of an electrical issue with the resolvers, it added.
Finally, the maker of the AOA sensors, Collins Aerospace, performed a fault-tree analysis to evaluate possible AOA vane failure scenarios caused by internal and external electrical faults. This analysis also considered every short circuit path to the AOA connector pins. The analysis found no electrical failure mode consistent with the circumstances of the accident, according to the NTSB.
The U.S. authority also called misleading the EAIB’s finding about the lack of MCAS documentation for flight crews because Boeing had provided the information to all 737 Max operators four months before the Ethiopian Airlines crash.
Although the NTSB acknowledges that information about the flap position required for MCAS to activate did not appear in Boeing’s flight crew operating manual (FCOM) bulletin and the FAA’s airworthiness directive in response to the crash of a Lion Air Max 8 on Oct. 29, 2018, Boeing provided the information in a multi-operator message (MOM-MOM-18-0664-01B) sent to all 737NG and Max customers on Nov.&nbsp;10, 2018.
Although the EAIB appended Boeing’s multi-operator message to the final report, the EAIB failed to mention that the flaps information appeared in that document—thus&nbsp;rendering the finding misleading, concluded the NTSB.
According to the NTSB’s most recent statement, the EAIB&nbsp;issued its final report without giving the U.S. regulator the chance to review and comment on new information incorporated since its last review, as stipulated by the International Civil Aviation Organization’s Annex 13.

News about significant aircraft accidents and information from accident reports.

NTSB Finds More Problems with Final Report on Ethiopian Airlines Boeing 737 Max 8 Crash

Ethiopian authorities say an electrical problem caused the Max 8’s left AOA sensor to fail, an assertion disputed by the NTSB. 

NTSB Finds More Problems with Final Report on ET Max Crash

2024 Corporate Aviation Leadership Summit

Matt Thurber

News and issues relating to business, corporate and private aviation, primarily regarding turbine-engine-powered airplanes and helicopters. Subjects include aircraft, engines, maintenance, operations, personnel, acquisitions, accidents, safety, security, and training.

Preparation and training resulted in a survivable accident

Bombardier Safety Standdown: Surviving the Fire

Aircraft caught fire and burned after hitting a vehicle

Five Killed in HondaJet Rejected Takeoff Crash at KFFZ

David Jack Kenny

Preliminary and final accident reports, November 2024

Business Aircraft Accident Reports: November 2024

Gordon Gilbert

Fatal accidents were down year over year from 12 to 10

Year-to-date Bizav Accidents Decline

Aircraft touched down on the runway then departed onto a grassy area

Passenger Lands King Air C90 after Pilot Medical Issue

Mark Huber

News and issues regarding all manner of civil and military rotorcraft and their powerplants, including helicopters, tilt rotors and unmanned air vehicles.

Black Hawk had landed on a private airstrip that was also a snowmobile trail

Snowmobiler Who Collided with Army Helo Awarded $3.3M

All five passengers drowned after autorotation into NYC's East River

Jury Awards $116M in Doors-off Helitour Crash

News about bills, laws, regulations and other governmental decisions affecting aviation and aerospace. Topics include FAA re-authorizations, taxes on fuel and aviation activities, environmental legislation, ICAO decisions, governmental mediation of labor conflicts and World Trade Organization disputes and decisions.

News and information on safety procedures and concerns.

More In Accidents