Voluntary safety programs are based on trust. Can you trust the FAA? The short answer, when it comes to voluntarily reporting violations or voluntarily cooperating with an FAA investigation, is no. You absolutely cannot trust the FAA to look out for your interests, especially the interests of maintaining your certificate or livelihood. In fact, you can expect the FAA to use anything and everything you say to them against you.
Let me explain. I haven’t felt this mistrustful of the FAA in a long time. Yes, of course, there was a time when no airman in his or her right mind trusted the FAA (we knew when the FAA showed up they weren’t there to help us) but then along came Asap, remedial training and other voluntary programs that encouraged cooperation with the agency, and the atmosphere in Flight Standards started to change. It seemed that starting sometime in the early years of the 21st century, the FAA figured out what many advanced aviation nations already knew: rigid, punitive enforcement systems don’t get far in encouraging airmen to come forward with safety information only they can know. Some FAA inspector sitting in an office isn’t going to know what’s happening on the line or in the hangar unless someone who actually flies the line or works in the hangar tells him.